Miscellaneous Essays, Commentary and Other Writings

1. An essay from Rabbi Aryeh Carmell written in support of the approach of the books

2. An essay from Rabbi Berel Wein on the topic of banning books

3. An audio recording of Rav Zev Leff answering a question about the ban on the books

4. A letter from Rabbi Chaim Malinowitz reiterating his support for the books

5. A letter from Rav Mordechai Gifter ztz"l concerning the age of the universe

6. Letter from Dr. Nachum Klafter to Rav Dovid Feinstein

7. "Authority and Wisdom: The Slifkin Affair" by Rabbi Benjamin Hecht

8. Two lectures (mp3 format) on "Secular Thinking," Part I and Part II, by Rabbi Yaakov Kalmanowitz, one of the primary forces behind the ban

9. "Ma'amar Mevo HaShemesh" - A booklet (in Hebrew) by Rabbi Pinchas David Weberman, editor of Sefer Hatekhuna of R Hayim Vital, which "proves" that heliocentrism is heresy. This is not directly related to the ban on the books, but it is highly relevant to the issues being discussed. The author's argument is that there is no traditional basis for this model and that the consensus of the Acharonim was to reject it as heresy. In this he is quite correct; nevertheless, the heliocentric model of the solar system is valid.

10. An essay from Rabbi Dr. Leo Levi, printed in the Jewish Observer, criticizing the banning process.

11. "Slifkin, Salem and the Senator" - A sharp sociological analysis of the controversy. This is a new version which includes a postscript.

Back to main page